Display Kept in this browser only
Docket Yard
Formal ComplaintBefore the Surface Transportation Board

NOR 42142

Docket Yard · docketyard.org/d/NOR-42142 · entries shown: all, newest first

CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY V. CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.

Caption from the Board’s record.

75 filings, 25 decisions and 0 environmental comments observed here; last checked 10 Oct 2026, 21:36 UTC; last new entry 26 Aug 2026, 15:46 UTC.

Cite View on stb.gov

Entries

By type (15)
Newest first · oldest first
  1. served (printed as 2/7/2019)
    Decision
    44833Entire Board
    DECISION GRANTED THE PARTIES' JOINT PETITION TO VACATE THE RATE PRESCRIPTION, DISMISS CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY'S COMPLAINT WITH PREJUDICE, AND DISCONTINUE THIS PROCEEDING.
  2. (printed as 1/28/2019)
    Motion
    246969Motion/Petition/Request
    Csx Transportation Inc, Consumers Energy Company
  3. served (printed as 9/27/2018)
    Decision
    46643--
    PROVIDED NOTICE THAT THE FOLLOWING COURT ACTION WAS INSTITUTED ON SEPTEMBER 25, 2018, IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT.
    in the court-action register
  4. served (printed as 9/24/2018)
    Decision
    46635--
    PROVIDED NOTICE THAT THE FOLLOWING COURT ACTION WAS INSTITUTED ON SEPTEMBER 20, 2018, IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT.
    in the court-action register
  5. served (printed as 8/2/2018)
    Decision
    46555Director Of Proceedings
    PROVIDED NOTICE OF A CORRECTION TO A DECISION SERVED IN THIS PROCEEDING.
  6. served (printed as 8/2/2018)
    Decision
    46521Entire Board
    DECISION (1) CONFIRMED ITS FINDING THAT THE RATE CHALLENGED BY THE COMPLAINING SHIPPER HAS BEEN SHOWN TO BE UNREASONABLY HIGH UNDER THE STAND-ALONE COST CONSTRAINT; (2) CONFIRMED ITS FINDING THAT THE COMPLAINING SHIPPER HAS NOT SHOWN THAT THE DEFENDANT RAILROAD IS REVENUE ADEQUATE UNDER THE REVENUE ADEQUACY CONSTRAINT; AND (3) THE MAXIMUM REASONABLE RATES PRESCRIBED IN THE UNDERLYING DECISION ARE MODIFIED TO ACCOUNT FOR CHANGES MADE TO RESOLVE PETITIONS FOR TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS AND PETITIONS FOR RECONSIDERATION.
  7. (printed as 8/2/2018)
    Section
    246155Section 5 Summary
    Surface Transportation Board
  8. (printed as 3/20/2018)
    Letter
    245341Letter
    Consumers Energy Company
  9. (printed as 3/19/2018)
    Motion
    245322Motion/Petition/Request
    Csx Transportation Inc
  10. served (printed as 3/14/2018)
    Decision
    46308Director Of Proceedings
    PROVIDED NOTICE THAT THE JANUARY 11, 2018 DECISION IS BEING UPDATED TO INCLUDE THE PUBLIC VERSION OF THE MARKET DOMINANCE APPENDIX SUBMITTED BY THE PARTIES ON FEBRUARY 7, 2018.
  11. (printed as 3/12/2018)
    Reply
    245298Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  12. (printed as 3/12/2018)
    Reply
    245297Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  13. (printed as 3/12/2018)
    Reply
    245296Reply
    Consumers Energy Company
  14. (printed as 2/20/2018)
    Motion
    245191Petition For Reconsideration
    Csx Transportation, Inc
  15. (printed as 2/20/2018)
    Motion
    245189Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company
  16. (printed as 2/20/2018)
    Motion
    245187Petition For Reconsideration
    Consumers Energy Company
  17. (printed as 2/20/2018)
    Motion
    245184Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company, Csx Transportation Inc
  18. (printed as 2/7/2018)
    Motion
    245132Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company, Csx Transportation, Inc
  19. served (printed as 1/19/2018)
    Decision
    46251Director Of Proceedings
    DESCISION GRANTED AN EXTENSION OF TIME IN THIS PROCEEDING.
  20. (printed as 1/19/2018)
    Substitution
    245016Substitution/Withdrawal Of Counsel
    Csx Transportation Inc
  21. (printed as 1/18/2018)
    Request
    245009Request For Extension Of Time
    Csx Transportation Inc
  22. (printed as 1/12/2018)
    Section
    244972Section 5 Summary
    Surface Transportation Board
  23. (printed as 1/12/2018)
    Section
    244971Section 5 Summary
    Surface Transportation Board
  24. served (printed as 1/11/2018)
    Decision
    46230Entire Board
    DECISION FOUND THAT THE COMPLAINING SHIPPER IN THIS PROCEEDING DOES NOT HAVE A FEASIBLE SHIPPING ALTERNATIVE TO THE DEFENDANT RAILROAD IN THIS PROCEEDING FOR THE TRANSPORTATION AT ISSUE, AND THAT THE RATE CHALLENGED BY THE COMPLAINING SHIPPER HAS BEEN DEMONSTRATED TO BE UNREASONABLY HIGH UNDER THE STAND-ALONE COST CONSTRAINT.
  25. (printed as 1/11/2018)
    Section
    244960Section 5 Summary
    Surface Transportation Board
  26. (printed as 1/11/2018)
    Section
    244959Section 5 Summary
    Surface Transportation Board
  27. (printed as 9/25/2017)
    Letter
    244428Letter
    Surface Transportation Board
  28. (printed as 9/19/2017)
    Letter
    244381Letter
    Bill Schuette
  29. (printed as 9/14/2017)
    Letter
    244330Letter
    Honorable Debbie Stabenow, Honorable Gary C. Peters
  30. (printed as 6/22/2017)
    Letter
    243830Letter
    Surface Transportation Board
  31. (printed as 6/15/2017)
    Letter
    243769Letter
    Honorable Tim Walberg, Honorable Debbie Dingell
  32. (printed as 5/23/2017)
    Reply
    243397Reply
    Consumers Energy Company
  33. (printed as 5/3/2017)
    Motion
    243011Motion To Strike
    Csx Transportation Inc
  34. (printed as 4/13/2017)
    Rebuttal
    242939Rebuttal
    Consumers Energy Company
  35. (printed as 3/6/2017)
    Reply
    242742Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  36. (printed as 1/23/2017)
    Evidence
    242501Evidence
    Consumers Energy Company
  37. served (printed as 12/9/2016)
    Decision
    45304Entire Board
    DECISION: (1) GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.'S MOTION TO STRIKE PORTIONS OF CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY'S REBUTTAL EVIDENCE; (2) ORDERED THE PARTIES TO SUBMIT SUPPLEMENTAL EVIDENCE ON MERCHANDISE TRAFFIC SELECTION AND EQUITY FLOTATION COSTS; AND (3) SET A PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE FOR THE SUBMISSION OF SUCH EVIDENCE.
  38. (printed as 7/26/2016)
    Reply
    241171Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  39. (printed as 7/14/2016)
    Reply
    241112Reply
    Consumers Energy Company
  40. (printed as 7/14/2016)
    Motion
    241111Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company
  41. (printed as 6/29/2016)
    Letter
    241007Letter
    Csx Transportation Inc.
  42. (printed as 6/27/2016)
    Motion
    240981Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company
  43. (printed as 6/24/2016)
    Brief
    240976Brief
    Consumers Energy Company
  44. (printed as 6/24/2016)
    Brief
    240972Brief
    Csx Transportation Inc
  45. (printed as 6/24/2016)
    Motion
    240969Motion To Strike
    Csx Transportation Inc
  46. served (printed as 6/17/2016)
    Decision
    45266Entire Board
    DECISION REJECTS CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.'S MAY 26, 2016 ERRATA FILING TO ITS REPLY EVIDENCE.
  47. served (printed as 6/3/2016)
    Decision
    45249Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION DIRECTED THE PARTIES TO PREPARE THEIR CLOSING BRIEFS IN THIS PROCEEDING ACCORDING TO CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS.
  48. (printed as 6/3/2016)
    Errata
    240859Errata Sheet
    Consumers Energy Company
  49. (printed as 6/1/2016)
    Statement
    240844Protest/Opposition Statement
    Csx Transportation Inc
  50. (printed as 5/27/2016)
    Reply
    240801Reply
    Consumers Energy Company
  51. (printed as 5/26/2016)
    Errata
    240786Errata Sheet
    Csx Transportation Inc
  52. (printed as 5/20/2016)
    Rebuttal
    240737Rebuttal
    Consumers Energy Company
  53. served (printed as 4/20/2016)
    Decision
    45154Director Of Proceedings
    DESCISION GRANTED IN PART CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY'S MOTION TO FURTHER MODIFY THE PROCEDULE SCHEDULE FOR 14 DAYS.
  54. (printed as 4/15/2016)
    Reply
    240510Reply
    Csx Transportation, Inc
  55. (printed as 4/13/2016)
    Motion
    240491Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company
  56. (printed as 4/8/2016)
    Reply
    240436Reply
    Csx Transportation, Inc
  57. served (printed as 4/6/2016)
    Decision
    45125Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION DENIED CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY'S PETITION FOR TECHNICAL CONFERENCE AND DIRECTED CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC. TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION BY APRIL 11, 2016.
  58. (printed as 3/21/2016)
    Reply
    240335Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  59. served (printed as 3/16/2016)
    Decision
    45105Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION DIRECTED CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC. TO FILE A RESPONSE TO CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY'S PETITION FOR TECHNICAL CONFERENCE BY MARCH 21, 2016.
  60. (printed as 3/14/2016)
    Motion
    240295Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company
  61. (printed as 3/8/2016)
    Errata
    240259Errata Sheet
    Csx Transportation Inc
  62. (printed as 3/7/2016)
    Reply
    240249Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc.
  63. (printed as 2/29/2016)
    Letter
    240220Letter
    State Of Michigan
  64. (printed as 2/23/2016)
    Letter
    240196Letter
    Senator Debbie Stabenow, Senator Gary C. Peters
  65. (printed as 2/19/2016)
    Letter
    240198Letter
    Michigan Public Power Agency
  66. (printed as 2/8/2016)
    Letter
    240209Letter
    Michigan Public Service Commission
  67. (printed as 1/20/2016)
    Letter
    239958Letter
    Honorable Tim Walberg, Honorable John Conyers, Jr., Honorable Candice S. Miller, Honorable Bill Huizenga, Honorable Justin Amash, Honorable Dan Benishek, Honorable Mike Bishop, Honorable Dave Trott, Honorable Sander Levin, Honorable Dan Kildee, Honorable Brenda Lawrence, Honorable Debbie Dingell, Honorable John Moolenaar
  68. (printed as 12/4/2015)
    Supplement
    239672Modify/Supplement Prior Filing Or The Record
    Consumers Energy Company
  69. (printed as 11/25/2015)
    Errata
    239629Errata Sheet
    Consumers Energy Company
  70. (printed as 11/2/2015)
    Statement
    239480Opening Statement
    Consumers Energy Company
  71. served (printed as 9/10/2015)
    Decision
    44729Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION GRANTED A REQUEST TO MODIFY THE PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE.
  72. (printed as 9/9/2015)
    Request
    239168Request For Extension Of Time
    Consumers Energy Company
  73. served (printed as 8/7/2015)
    Decision
    44666Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION GRANTED THE MOTION FILED BY CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY TO WITHDRAW AND DEFER THE SECOND MOTION TO COMPEL.
  74. (printed as 8/5/2015)
    Motion
    238978Motion To Withdraw
    Consumers Energy Company
  75. served (printed as 7/15/2015)
    Decision
    44524Entire Board
    DECISION ADOPTED PROCEDURES FOR THE FORMAT OF EVIDENCE TO BE PRESENTED FOR THE MARKET DOMINANCE INQUIRY AND THE STAND-ALONE COST CLAIM FOR THIS CASE.
  76. (printed as 7/15/2015)
    Report
    238825Status Report
    Csx Transportation Inc., Consumers Energy Company
  77. served (printed as 7/13/2015)
    Decision
    44579Director Of Proceedings
    PROVIDED NOTICE THAT THE BOARD HAS SCHEDULED A CONFERENCE ON JULY 20, 2015.
  78. (printed as 7/13/2015)
    Letter
    238811Letter
    Surface Transportation Board
  79. (printed as 7/6/2015)
    Reply
    238752Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  80. (printed as 6/29/2015)
    Substitution
    238709Substitution/Withdrawal Of Counsel
    Csx Transportation Inc
  81. (printed as 6/25/2015)
    Motion
    238707Motion To Compel
    Consumers Energy Company
  82. served (printed as 6/15/2015)
    Decision
    44523Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION PROVIDED NOTICE TO THE PARTIES THAT A TECHNICAL CONFERENCE WILL BE HELD ON TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 2015, AT 10:00 A.M., AT THE BOARD'S HEADQUARTERS AT 395 E STREET, S.W., WASHINGTON, DC.
  83. served (printed as 6/15/2015)
    Decision
    44521Entire Board
    DECISION DENIES A MOTION TO DISMISS CONSUMER ENERGY COMPANY'S REVENUE ADEQUACY CLAIM.
  84. served (printed as 4/27/2015)
    Decision
    44445Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION GRANTED CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY AND CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.'S MOTIONS TO WITHDRAW.
  85. (printed as 4/22/2015)
    Motion
    238256Motion To Withdraw
    Csx Transportation Inc.
  86. served (printed as 4/16/2015)
    Decision
    44437Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION PROVIDED NOTICE TO THE PARTIES THAT A CONFERENCE WILL BE HELD IN THIS PROCEEDING ON TUESDAY, APRIL 21, 2015, AT 10:00 A.M., AT THE BOARD'S HEADQUARTERS AT 395 E STREET, S.W., WASHINGTON, DC.
  87. (printed as 4/13/2015)
    Reply
    238195Reply
    Consumers Energy Company
  88. (printed as 4/13/2015)
    Reply
    238191Reply
    Consumers Energy Company
  89. served (printed as 4/10/2015)
    Decision
    44410Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION GRANTED A JOINT MOTION TO ADOPT THE PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE.
  90. (printed as 4/10/2015)
    Report
    238184Status Report
    Csx Transportation Inc, Consumers Energy Company
  91. served (printed as 4/3/2015)
    Decision
    44406Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION ORDERED: (1) CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY (CONSUMERS) AND CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC. TO MEET AND CONFER ON THE DISCOVERY ISSUES RAISED IN CONSUMERS' MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY; (2) PARTIES ARE FURTHER INSTRUCTED TO REPORT TO THE BOARD BY APRIL 10, 2015, ON THE STATUS OF DISCOVERY ISSUES AND WHETHER THERE ARE ANY ISSUES THAT CANNOT BE RESOLVED.
  92. (printed as 4/2/2015)
    Motion
    238121Motion/Petition/Request
    Consumers Energy Company, Csx Transportation Inc.
  93. (printed as 4/2/2015)
    Motion
    238119Motion To Compel
    Csx Transportation Inc
  94. (printed as 3/26/2015)
    Reply
    238052Reply
    Csx Transportation Inc
  95. (printed as 3/24/2015)
    Motion
    238028Motion To Dismiss Or Discontinue
    Csx Transportation Inc
  96. served (printed as 3/18/2015)
    Decision
    44374Director Of Proceedings
    DECISION GRANTED JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER.
  97. (printed as 3/16/2015)
    Motion
    237958Motion To Compel
    Consumers Energy Company
  98. (printed as 2/27/2015)
    Motion
    237820Motion For Protective Order
    Csx Transportation Inc., Consumers Energy Company
    in the protective-order register
  99. (printed as 2/2/2015)
    Answer
    237656Answer
    Csx Transportation Inc
  100. (printed as 1/13/2015)
    Complaint
    237459Complaint
    Consumers Energy Company