Display Kept in this browser only
Formal ComplaintBefore the Surface Transportation Board

NOR 42069

DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION V. NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY

Caption from the Board’s record.

59 filings, 26 decisions and 0 environmental comments observed here; last checked 10 Oct 2026, 21:36 UTC; last new entry 26 Aug 2026, 15:26 UTC.

Entries

By type (9)
Newest first · oldest first
  1. Decision
    36010Secretary
    GRANTED THE COMPLAINANTS' SEPARATELY FILED MOTIONS TO DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE THE COMPLAINTS IN STB DOCKET NOS. 42069, 42070, AND 42072, AND DISMISSED AS MOOT THE COMPLAINANTS' APPEALS SEEKING ACCESS TO ADDITIONAL INFORMATION IN THE COSTED WAYBILL SAMPLE.
  2. Motion
    214240Motion To Dismiss Or Discontinue
    Duke Energy Corporation
  3. Decision
    35880Secretary
    EXTENDED THE DUE DATE FOR FILING OPENING STATEMENTS BY 30 DAYS AND MODIFIED IN A CORRESPONDING MANNER THE DEADLINES FOR REPLY STATEMENTS, REBUTTAL STATEMENTS, AND BRIEFS.
  4. Request
    213989Request For Extension Of Time
    Duke Energy Corporation, Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  5. Decision
    35809Secretary
    GRANTED DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION AND CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY'S MOTIONS TO MODIFY THE PROCEDURAL SCHEDULES, AS ESTABLISHED IN THE JANUARY 6, 2005 DECISION.
  6. Request
    213766Request For Extension Of Time
    Duke Energy Corporation
  7. Decision
    35735Secretary
    COMPLAINANTS' JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY IS DENIED.
  8. Decision
    35681Secretary
    GRANTED DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION AND CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY'S MOTIONS TO COMPEL DISCOVERY OF RAIL TRANSPORTATION CONTRACTS, AS SPECIFIED IN THIS DECISION.
  9. Reply
    213593Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  10. Motion
    213526Motion To Compel
    Duke Energy Corporation, Carolina Power & Light Company
  11. Reply
    213514Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  12. Motion
    213495Motion To Compel
    Duke Energy Corporation
  13. Decision
    35664Secretary
    ESTABLISHED A PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE FOR MOTIONS TO COMPEL IN THIS PROCEEDING.
  14. Request
    213468Request For Extension Of Time
    Duke Energy Corportaion, Norfolk Southern Corporation
  15. Reply
    213390Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  16. Appeal
    213272Appeal
    Duke Energy Corporation, Carolina Power & Light Company
  17. Decision
    35475Secretary
    SET A PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE FOR THE FILING OF EVIDENCE.
  18. Decision
    35391Secretary
    PROVIDED NOTICE THAT A COURT ACTION WAS INSTITUTED IN THIS PROCEEDING ON OR ABOUT NOVEMBER 19, 2004, BEFORE THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT.
  19. Reply
    212608Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  20. Reply
    212580Reply
    Duke Energy Corporation
  21. Decision
    34932Entire Board
    (1) MODIFIED THE BOARD'S PRIOR DECISIONS IN THESE THREE EASTERN RAIL RATE CASES (STB DOCKET NO. 42069, STB DOCKET NO. 42070, AND STB DOCKET NO. 42072); AND (2) FOUND THAT NONE OF THE CHALLENGED RATES SHOWN TO BE UNREASONABLE UNDER THE STAND-ALONE COST TEST.
  22. Decision
    35167Secretary
    ANNOUNCED THE AGENDA ITEMS TO BE DISCUSSED AT THE BOARD'S OCTOBER 20, 2004 VOTING CONFERENCE.
  23. Supplement
    210438Modify/Supplement Prior Filing Or The Record
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  24. Reply
    210306Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  25. Reply
    210305Reply
    Duke Energy Corporation
  26. Motion
    210135Petition For Reconsideration
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  27. Motion
    210134Petition For Reconsideration
    Duke Energy Corporation
  28. Decision
    34320Entire Board
    GRANTED IN PART THE PETITION OF DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION, SEEKING CERTAIN TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS IN THE BOARD'S DECISION SERVED ON NOVEMBER 6, 2003, IN THIS PROCEEDING.
  29. Letter
    209657Letter
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  30. Letter
    209655Letter
    Duke Energy Corporation
  31. Reply
    209510Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  32. Decision
    34233Commissioner
    (1) STAYED THE BOARD'S NOVEMBER 6, 2003 DECISION PENDING THE BOARD'S REVIEW OF TECHNICAL ISSUES AND FURTHER ACTION; AND (2) TOLLED THE 20-DAY PERIOD FOR PARTIES TO FILE MOTIONS FOR RECONSIDERATION AND THE 30-DAY PERIOD FOR DUKE TO INFORM THE BOARD ABOUT THE PHASING OPTION PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE BOARD.
  33. Reply
    209463Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  34. Decision
    34219Entire Board
    NOTICE OF A CORRECTION TO THE BOARD'S DECISION SERVED ON NOVEMBER 6, 2003 IN THIS PROCEEDING.
  35. Motion
    209440Motion/Petition/Request
    Duke Energy Corporation
  36. Motion
    209439Petition For Stay
    Duke Energy Corporation
  37. Letter
    209396Letter
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  38. Decision
    34015Entire Board
    BOARD FOUND THAT THE CHALLENGED RATES HAVE NOT BEEN SHOWN TO BE UNREASONABLE UNDER THE STAND-ALONE COST RATE REASONABLENESS TEST.
  39. Reply
    209286Reply
    Duke Energy Corporation
  40. Reply
    209277Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  41. Comments
    209212Comment
    Duke Energy Corporation
  42. Comments
    209209Comment
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  43. Decision
    34103Entire Board
    REOPENED THE RECORD FOR THE LIMITED PURPOSE OF AFFORDING THE PARTIES AN OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT NEEDED SUPPLEMENTAL EVIDENCE TO COMPLETE THE RECORD IN THIS PROCEEDING.
  44. Decision
    33613Secretary
    GRANTED THE PROPOSALS TO MODIFY PROTECTIVE ORDERS ISSUED IN 12 STAND-ALONE COST RAIL RATE PROCEEDINGS.
  45. Comments
    207767Comment
    Duke Energy Corportaion
  46. Decision
    33519Secretary
    DIRECTED THAT PARTIES TO THE CAPTIONED STAND-ALONE COST PROCEEDINGS SHOULD REVIEW AND JOINTLY PROPOSE ANY NECESSARY MODIFICATIONS OF THE PROTECTIVE ORDERS GOVERNING THESE PROCEEDINGS BY MAY 9, 2003.
  47. Decision
    33401Entire Board
    GRANTS THE REQUEST FILED BY DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION TO REJECT NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY'S TABLES SUBMITTED ALONG WITH ITS BRIEF IN THIS MAXIMUM RATE REASONABLENESS COMPLAINT PROCEEDING.
  48. Decision
    33453Secretary
    NOTICE THAT THE BOARD WILL CONDUCT A VOTING CONFERENCE ON FRIDAY, MARCH 21, 2003, AT 9:30 A.M.
  49. Reply
    207155Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  50. Comments
    207133Comment
    Duke Energy Corporation
  51. Letter
    207105Letter
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  52. Reply
    207095Reply
    Duke Energy Corportaion
  53. Decision
    33336Secretary
    DIRECTED THE PARTIES TO SUBMIT A LIST OF REPLACEMENT REFERENCES TO WORKPAPERS AND TABLES OF CONTENTS IN THESE CASES BY JANUARY 17, 2003.
  54. Errata
    206909Errata Sheet
    Duke Energy Corporation
  55. Decision
    33256Secretary
    (1) GRANTED DUKE ENERGY AND NS'S JOINT MOTION TO ESTABLISH A SCHEDULE FOR SUBMISSION OF CLOSING BRIEFS IN STB DOCKET NO. 42069; (2) GRANTED DUKE ENERGY AND CSXT'S JOINT MOTION TO ESTABLISH A BRIEFING SCHEDULE IN STB DOCKET NO. 42070; AND (3) GRANTED CP&L AND NS'S JOINT MOTION TO ESTABLISH A BRIEFING SCHEDULE IN STB DOCKET NO. 42072.
  56. Motion
    206761Motion/Petition/Request
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  57. Errata
    206529Errata Sheet
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  58. Supplement
    206453Modify/Supplement Prior Filing Or The Record
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  59. Supplement
    206338Modify/Supplement Prior Filing Or The Record
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  60. Decision
    32963Secretary
    GRANTED THE JOINT REQUEST BY COMPLAINANT DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION AND DEFENDANT NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY TO ESTABLISH A NEW SCHEDULE FOR THE FILING OF REPLY AND REBUTTAL STATEMENTS.
  61. Motion
    205997Motion/Petition/Request
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company, Duke Energy Corporation
  62. Decision
    32630Secretary
    (1) ACCEPTED DUKE ENERGY'S AMENDED COMPLAINTS FILED APRIL 5, 2002, AS MODIFIED APRIL 24, 2002; (2) GRANTED THE MOTIONS TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF DUKE ENERGY'S COAL SUPPLY CONTRACTS, RELATED DOCUMENTS, AND THE OTHER THIRD-PARTY CONFIDENTIAL MATERIALS DISCUSSED IN THIS PROCEEDING, SUBJECT TO THE PROTECTIVE ORDERS SERVED IN THESE PROCEEDINGS ON FEBRUARY 5, 2002; (3) DIRECTED DUKE ENERGY TO SUPPLY THE INFORMATION IT HAS AGREED TO FURNISH; AND (4) DENIED IN ALL OTHER RESPECTS, THE MOTIONS TO COMPEL.
  63. Reply
    205836Reply
    Norfolk Southern Corporation
  64. Reply
    205824Reply
    Duke Energy Corporation
  65. Motion
    205808Petition For Modification
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  66. Letter
    205254Letter
    Duke Energy Corportaion
  67. Motion
    205207Motion To Strike
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  68. Reply
    205206Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  69. Decision
    32658Secretary
    GRANTED THE JOINT REQUEST FOR A NEW PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE.
  70. Supplement
    205137Modify/Supplement Prior Filing Or The Record
    Duke Energy Corporation
  71. Request
    205072Request For Extension Of Time
    Duke Energy Corporation, Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  72. Letter
    205066Letter
    Dayton Power And Light Company
  73. Reply
    204984Reply
    Duke Energy Corporation
  74. Letter
    204942Letter
    Integrity Coal Sales Inc
  75. Letter
    205134Letter
    Abc Coke
  76. Decision
    32561Secretary
    GRANTED DUKE ENERGY'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY OF RAIL TRANSPORTATION CONTRACTS, AS SPECIFIED IN THIS DECISION.
  77. Appeal
    204896Appeal Arbitration Decision
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  78. Letter
    205135Letter
    Applalachin Power Company
  79. Reply
    204849Reply
    Southern Company Services Inc
  80. Reply
    204741Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  81. Decision
    32509Secretary
    (1) GRANTED THE JOINT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER; (2) DIRECTED THE PARTIES TO COMPLY WITH THE PROTECTIVE ORDER IN THE APPENDIX OF THIS DECISION; AND (3) SET A PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE.
  82. Appeal
    204698Appeal Arbitration Decision
    Duke Energy Corporation
  83. Reply
    204334Reply
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company
  84. Motion
    204320Motion For Protective Order
    Norfolk Southern Railway Company, Duke Energy Corporation
  85. Report
    204319Status Report
    Duke Energy Corporation, Norfolk Southern Railway Company