{"source":"https://docketyard.org/","licence":"CC0-1.0","licence_url":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","shape_version":3,"held":{"enriched":"The party module (entity resolution, aliases, successions), the citator (citation edges, their readings, resolutions and judgements) and the machine-read text of the record's documents (every reading, its payload and its index) are derived work whose licence awaits review; they are withheld until then, not dedicated by default."},"generated_at":"2026-10-11T05:01:15+00:00","docket":{"docket_id":31436,"raw_docket":"NOR_41670_0","prefix":"NOR","sequence":41670,"title":"SHELL CHEMICAL COMPANY AND SHELL OIL COMPANY V. NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY","sub_dockets":[],"is_index":false,"entries":[{"kind":"decision","date":"1999-03-12","date_printed":"3/12/1999","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"30109","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"GRANTED COMPLAINANTS MOTION FILED MARCH 11, 1999, TO DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE THE COMPLAINT FILED IN THIS PROCEEDING ON DECEMBER 24, 1995, AND DISCONTINUED THIS PROCEEDING.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/7C5E07373CD0E6B9852567310079DE6C/30109.pdf","label":"30109.pdf","document_sha256":"8e1f6e124dddad34d7d3611aca5296d7e5ff353ab26324f1223687c3b8d2410c","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/30109"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1999-01-28","date_printed":"1/28/1999","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"30002","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"GRANTED THE JOINT MOTION FILED JANUARY 25, 1999 BY COMPLAINANTS AND DEFENDANTS FOR A 45-DAY EXTENSION OF THE PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE ADOPTED IN DECISION NO. 27.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/E25C8ED92CA211BB8525670600587DB2/30002.pdf","label":"30002.pdf","document_sha256":"2f0c62a6a8ca9eec8586933ddfdd876f8d5640932c0a89b71d007307047a9ea7","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/30002"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1998-12-11","date_printed":"12/11/1998","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"29851","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"GRANTED COMPLAINANTS AND DEFENDANTS REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF THE PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/A100A34F6348746F852566D6005E3D1D/29851.pdf","label":"29851.pdf","document_sha256":"f04326c704601ccbeb14c40ab0d3ab620927d6b7a3687aeeed1bc4d7bc7768d4","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/29851"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1998-12-01","date_printed":"12/1/1998","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"29826","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"ADOPTED THE PARTIES' PROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR SUBMISSIONS OF EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENT.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/BD6D92BC0BA5C1CB852566CC0066934C/29826.pdf","label":"29826.pdf","document_sha256":"59e918b694222cbd78ebe25e098b0b63f45c5f252dd6f284e8b0d754af151506","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/29826"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1998-04-23","date_printed":"4/23/1998","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"29129","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Entire Board","summary":"(1) FOUND THAT THE SIX INDIVIDUALS WHOM DEFENDANTS SEEK TO DEPOSE APPEAR TO HAVE FIRST-HAND KNOWLEDGE OF FACTS THAT MAY BE MATERIAL TO THE MARKET DOMINANCE DETERMINATION IN THIS PROCEEDING; (2) DEFENDANTS' REQUESTS FOR DEPOSITIONS WERE MADE PROMPTLY AFTER THE PENDING DISCOVERY ISSUES WERE RESOLVED, THEREFORE, WE WILL PERMITS THE DEPOSITIONS TO GO FORWARD.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/DC949B674D670560852565E70068F038/29129.pdf","label":"29129.pdf","document_sha256":"fd4f266facb0c7972c766bdb11c50c2e465224a042d2cb5a59602e69083fd810","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/29129"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1998-04-06","date_printed":"4/6/1998","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"29094","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"GRANTED COMPLAINANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS, AND THE COMPLAINT IS DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE AS TO DEFENDANT CONSOLIDATED RAIL CORPORATION.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/40466367805FBF28852565D900584858/29094.pdf","label":"29094.pdf","document_sha256":"7d475e0b04930a055d6f2f8caeb40d44deb7545749adc83ef6659ba11ff77b57","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/29094"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-12-15","date_printed":"12/15/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"28602","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Entire Board","summary":"(1) DENIED COMPLAINANTS' MOTION TO STRIKE; (2) ACCEPTED DEFENDANTS' REPLIES FOR FILING AND MADE A PARTY OF RECORD; (3) GRANTED IN PART COMPLAINANTS' MOTION INSOFAR AS IT SEEKS ACCEPTANCE OF SURREBUTTAL MATERIAL; (4) GRANTED IN PART DEFENDANTS SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES; AND (5) DIRECTED COMPLAINANTS TO FURNISH THEIR RESPONSES TO DEFENDANTS BY 12/29/97.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/3A599B64A1D1550485256559006E4EA7/28602.pdf","label":"28602.pdf","document_sha256":"b4f7b34c83c049e1e7710b717efdfcde344186b29355ba154b0817b8f37ce9cd","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/28602"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-09-08","date_printed":"9/8/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"28209","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"GRANTED COMPLAINANTS MOTION FILED 8-15-97.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/F2AB349CB735868A85256542004D7B54/28209.pdf","label":"28209.pdf","document_sha256":"776f132de44f9b6360490bae912cbb1e4be7d034971ac9390c9d47d1d6119831","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/28209"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-08-27","date_printed":"8/27/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"28095","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Entire Board","summary":"ADDRESSED A DISCOVERY MATTER COMPLETELY RESOLVED IN DECISION NO. 19, SERVED JUNE 26, 1997; AND CLARIFIES CERTAIN DETAILS RESPECTING THE ELECTRONIC SUBMISSIONS REQUESTED OF THE PARTIES.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/C5B4C27F994B816985256542004D29C1/28095.pdf","label":"28095.pdf","document_sha256":"281900387b2c6b4ec70f5c28541c6ac724394a0bf1d340c4d25aeb497df3b782","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/28095"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-07-25","date_printed":"7/25/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"28094","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"GRANTED TO DISMISS MOTION AND COMPLAINT WITH PREJUDICE.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/8A0719C277FA1EDF85256542004D28D5/28094.pdf","label":"28094.pdf","document_sha256":"cbd076a1bde7405946d58e92bf123c2e837014819bc6be3c3e4b59a3096b137f","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/28094"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-06-26","date_printed":"6/26/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"27954","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Entire Board","summary":"DENIED COMPLAINTS SECOND MOTION TO COMPEL, AND COMPLAINTS' PETITION.","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/2E2D5BD6EDADFE9A85256542004CAC2D/27954.pdf","label":"27954.pdf","document_sha256":"6e7aa5cee8bf7dc54338038bf0c42fbd1be6e0cac34cb6ac2a984adaf35fad0d","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/27954"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-06-02","date_printed":"6/2/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"25593","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"--","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/535BB4A41FC7B6C585256542004C5472/25593.pdf","label":"25593.pdf","document_sha256":"afc237df89ea89832f8e3da2f1e8ff63a301d7c92e0e130d69ae0ee8893ea0ce","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/25593"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1997-05-14","date_printed":"5/14/1997","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"25569","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"--","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/69FF1DB1BCA902BA85256542004C4372/25569.pdf","label":"25569.pdf","document_sha256":"643369d6996891ecfc9c66432471b3c8e9d37bbe9aa0e1859cded196d93da173","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/25569"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1996-12-11","date_printed":"12/11/1996","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"21277","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"--","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/0C731DD3A084134A852565480078FD0F/21277.pdf","label":"21277.pdf","document_sha256":"578e79b5fdfb7bbda7eda38143604a6918f4ba51d339b221920ac4ff4cdbda84","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/21277"},{"kind":"decision","date":"1996-12-03","date_printed":"12/3/1996","docket_raw":"NOR_41670_0","record_id":"21199","type":"Decision","filed_for_raw":null,"deciding_body":"Secretary","summary":"--","attachments":[{"url":"https://dcms-external.s3.amazonaws.com/MPD/62491/AB493C61F3A36C81852565480078FC95/21199.pdf","label":"21199.pdf","document_sha256":"9adb7d313519883507501ad3c2955d69229584ddc54eeef933f0e7f1e732c6ab","media_type":"pdf"}],"also_in":[],"submitter":null,"organisation":null,"location":null,"comment_text":null,"date_kind":"served","url":"https://docketyard.org/decision/21199"}],"filings":0,"decisions":15,"comments":0,"last_checked":"2026-10-11T04:36:35+00:00","last_new_entry":"2026-08-26T15:15:27+00:00","series":null,"printed":"NOR 41670","url":"https://docketyard.org/d/NOR-41670"}}